問 1
What is the main idea of the passage?
- Coral reefs are doomed regardless of any human intervention, so restoration efforts are pointless.
- Scientists have discovered a reliable method that can fully reverse the global decline of coral reefs.
- Assisted evolution has already replaced coral transplanting as the standard restoration technique.
- Hands-on coral restoration can help reefs survive, but it cannot substitute for tackling the warming that threatens them.
They describe their work not as a cure but as a form of triage
本文は「手作業の珊瑚再生は延命策にはなるが、温暖化対策の代わりにはならない」が論旨。
「Hands-on coral restoration can help reefs survive, but it cannot substitute for tackling the warming that threatens them.」
正解本文は (1) 珊瑚礁が急速に衰退している→ (2) 科学者が手作業で再生を始めた (移植・assisted evolution)→ (3) しかし規模が小さく、炭素排出削減の代わりにはならない、という構成。最終段の not a cure but ... triage / depends ... on choices made far from the water が結論で、「再生は延命に役立つが温暖化対策の代用にはならない」が主旨。
「Scientists have discovered a reliable method that can fully reverse the global decline of coral reefs.」
= 完全に逆転できる確実な手法を発見した ━ 本文は restoration を cure ではなく triage と明言し、規模が全く足りないと述べているので『完全逆転』は言い過ぎ。
「Coral reefs are doomed regardless of any human intervention, so restoration efforts are pointless.」
= どうせ滅びるので無意味 ━ 本文は再生を buying time / preserving diversity として価値を認めており『無意味』とは正反対。
「Assisted evolution has already replaced coral transplanting」
= 既に移植に取って代わった ━ assisted evolution は『一部の科学者が転じた』新手法で、移植を置換した事実はない。
| パターン | 意味 | 例 |
|---|---|---|
| shelter ~ species | ~の種を宿す | Reefs shelter a quarter of marine species. |
| accelerating decline | 加速する衰退 | their accelerating decline |
| rebuild ~ by hand | ~を手作業で再建する | begun to rebuild the reefs by hand |
| not A but B | AではなくB | not a cure but a form of triage |
| buy time | 時間を稼ぐ | buying time for a reckoning |
Reefs shelter a quarter of all marine species.
珊瑚礁は全海洋種の四分の一を宿す。
They describe the work not as a cure but as triage.
彼らはその活動を治療ではなく応急処置だと説明する。
Restoration buys time but does not stop the warming.
再生は時間を稼ぐが温暖化は止めない。
主旨設問は最終段の対比構文 (not A but B) と結論文を探す。本文は『手段は有効だが根本原因は別』という逆接型の主張。